Messy Art Is Still Art
The wax did not move the way I wanted it to move.
That was the first lesson.
On Sunday, I went to Kampung Batik Giriloyo in Bantul, where I learned about the history of batik and made a small batik cloth of my own. I knew, before I even sat down, that I was not arriving as a skilled visual artist. I can live inside a poem for hours. I can revise a line until it stops wobbling. But give me cloth, wax, dye, and a tool I do not know how to hold, and I become a beginner in the most obvious way.
There is no hiding in that kind of making. The hand shakes. The wax pools. The flower becomes a splotch. The imagination and the object refuse to match.
That experience became my Day 12 poem for the 30/30 Project for Tupelo Press. If you like what you read, please donate to Tupelo Press. They help keep poets writing, and this project is one way to honor the daily labor of art, even when the work comes out crooked, stained, or strange.
A morning with hot wax and unfamiliar hands
Kampung Batik Giriloyo is known for batik, and being there meant entering a practice with deep roots. Batik is not just a pattern on fabric. It is a process of patience, control, repetition, heat, resistance, and release. Wax is drawn onto cloth to protect certain areas from dye. The cloth is dyed, boiled, rinsed, dried. What remains is both design and memory.
I understood this in the abstract before I sat down.
Then the hot wax arrived.
The stool was low. My legs were too long for it. The air carried the smell of wax, thick and slightly dizzying. I held the drawing tool, called a canting, and tried to follow the shape I meant to make. I wanted flowers. Soft ones, maybe. Deliberate ones. Something simple enough that I could complete it without causing too much damage.
The cloth had other plans.
Wax does not forgive hesitation. It does not translate intention into beauty just because intention is sincere. It falls where it falls. It thickens. It smears. It makes the private awkwardness of the hand visible.
I found myself thinking, almost immediately, this is not the art that I know.
That thought surprised me. I do not believe art has to be polished to matter. I know poems can begin in fragments, bad drafts, crossed-out lines, and failed titles. I know process can look ugly before it becomes clear. Still, when the mess belonged to my hand in another medium, I felt embarrassed.
Embarrassment is a strict teacher. It brings old voices with it.
The poem
Here is the poem that came from that day.
Batik Katerina Canyon I sit on a stool too short for my long legs and made myself dizzy from the smell of hot wax. I use an unfamiliar tool to draw flowers onto cotton cloth. It is not slow or meditative. my flowers are smeared splotches. This is not the art that I know. I cannot help but think of my mother’s sighs when I failed at calligraphy, and watercolors and needlepoint. So instead, I stand, and watch the real artist fix my errors and boil the cloth, dye it royal blue. I kneel to rinse and scrub it clean. As my batik suns on a bush, I sit and breathe in the wind. It is time for prayer somewhere because I hear the Muezzin. The tall grass dances in the breeze. When my batik dries, I realize messy art is still art.
The old fear of being bad at something
The poem moves quickly from the stool to memory. That is how failure often works. One small mistake opens a door, and behind it stands every former mistake, waiting to be recognized.
I thought of calligraphy. Watercolors. Needlepoint.
I thought of the particular pain of disappointing someone who wanted me to be good at something. Not good in the vague, encouraging sense. Good in the visible sense. Neat. Skilled. Worth showing.
Some arts carry an immediate record of failure. In handwriting, the line either trembles or it does not. In watercolor, the color either blooms beautifully or it muddies. In needlepoint, the stitches either align or they tangle. There are no private drafts when someone can look down and see the evidence.
Poetry has visible failures too, of course. A weak line sits there. A false image announces itself. A poem can collapse under its own dramatic weight. But poetry also allows revision to hide the early mess. By the time a reader sees the finished poem, the bad versions have usually disappeared.
Batik did not offer me that privacy.
My smeared flowers stayed in front of me. They were not symbolic yet. They were just smeared flowers. I did what many beginners do when the gap between desire and ability gets too wide. I stepped back. I watched someone with skill repair what I could not.
There was humility in that, and some relief.
The real artist did not treat the cloth as ruined. That mattered. Where I saw errors, they saw material. They knew what could be saved, what could be altered, what could disappear into dye. They knew the next step.
That is one of the gifts of learning from someone who has practiced a craft for years. A beginner often thinks a mistake is an ending. A maker knows it is usually a stage.
The dye changed everything
I appreciated the dyeing process more than the drawing process.
Part of that was practical. I did not have to pretend my hand knew what it was doing. The cloth moved into water, heat, color, and rinsing. The process became physical in a different way. Less about precision. More about transformation.
The cloth was boiled. It was dyed royal blue. I knelt to rinse and scrub it clean.
There is something honest about rinsing. The cloth changes under your hands, but not all at once. Excess dye releases into the water. Wax loosens. The image begins to appear. You do not command it into being. You keep working, and then you recognize it.
That part felt closer to writing.
A poem can begin as a mess of notes, overheard phrases, half-images, and emotional pressure. At first, it often looks like nothing. Then a repeated sound appears. A line arrives that knows more than the poet does. A memory attaches itself to an object. You rinse. You scrub. You remove what clouds the work.
At some point, something appears that was not visible at the start.
The dye did not erase my mistakes. It changed my relationship to them. The splotches no longer sat there as proof that I had failed at beauty. They became part of the cloth’s record. Part of its surface. Part of its life.
That is the line I needed the day to give me. Messy Art Is Still Art, not because mess is automatically profound, but because making is allowed to show the hand that made it.
The sound of the Muezzin and the pause after making
After the cloth was rinsed and set out to dry, there was nothing left for me to fix.
That pause felt important.
The batik sunned on a bush. I sat and breathed in the wind. Somewhere nearby, it was time for prayer, and I heard the Muezzin. The tall grass moved. The day widened.
Some art experiences are loud with effort. They make the body tense. They expose every place where skill has not caught up to desire. But after the effort, if we are lucky, there is a moment when the work no longer asks anything from us.
It simply exists.
I needed that moment more than I expected. I needed to stop judging the cloth while it was still drying. I needed to sit near it without trying to improve it. I needed to let the world keep happening around the object I had made badly and earnestly.
That is not passivity. It is part of the practice.
Writers know this too. Sometimes a draft needs to sit. Sometimes the mind needs to stop pressing on it. Sometimes the poem has to dry on the bush while the body remembers it belongs to the weather, to sound, to hunger, to prayer, to the long grass moving whether or not the poem succeeds.
The pause after making can be as revealing as the making itself.
What beginners teach us about art
Being a beginner is uncomfortable because it removes the armor of identity.
If I say I am a poet, I can stand inside years of practice. I can point to the work, the discipline, the vocabulary. I know what a line break can do. I know when an image feels false. I know how to wait for a poem.
But when I sat with the batik cloth, I could not bring that authority with me. The canting tool did not care that I write poems. The wax did not care that I understand metaphor. The flower did not become a flower because I had feelings about it.
That kind of helplessness can be good for an artist.
It reminds us that every art form has its own intelligence. A poet cannot simply walk into batik and expect language skills to become visual skill. A painter cannot automatically write a sonnet. A dancer cannot assume rhythm alone will make a sculpture stand.
Respect begins there.
Not all difficulty is failure. Sometimes difficulty is the form telling us how it wants to be approached. Batik asked for steadiness, heat tolerance, patience, and trust in stages I did not fully understand. I arrived with impatience and a romantic idea of making something beautiful. The practice corrected me.
That correction was generous.
It gave me a poem.
It also gave me a small cloth I would not have designed if I had full control. That may be why I like it now. It carries the evidence of my limits, but it also carries the evidence of my participation.
Supporting the daily practice of poetry
The 30/30 Project asks poets to show up every day and make something. That daily practice does not produce perfection. It produces attention. It creates a record of days, places, moods, failures, surprises, and returns.
Day 12 came from Bantul, from Kampung Batik Giriloyo, from hot wax, from embarrassment, from blue dye, from the sound of prayer, from grass in the wind, from a cloth drying on a bush.
That is one reason I value projects like this. They make room for poems that might not wait for ideal conditions. They remind me that a poem does not always begin at a desk. It can begin with a stool that is too short, a tool held badly, a memory of a mother’s sigh, or the sudden realization that a flawed object still belongs to the world of made things.
If this poem reaches you, I hope you will consider supporting Tupelo Press. Small presses do vital work for poetry. They publish, encourage, and sustain voices that might otherwise go unheard. Donations help keep that work alive, and they help poets keep writing through the messy middle of the process.
Keeping the imperfect thing
When my batik dried, I could see that it was not what I had imagined.
It was also not nothing.
That distinction matters. So much art is abandoned in the space between the imagined work and the actual one. The imagined version is clean. The actual version has awkward edges. The imagined version proves talent. The actual version proves that a person tried.
I am trying to love the actual version more.
The cloth I made in Bantul is not evidence that I am secretly a visual artist. It is not a hidden masterpiece. It is a small, messy object made during an afternoon when I was willing to be bad at something and stay present anyway.
That is enough.
Maybe that is more than enough.
The poem ends where the day ended for me, with recognition. Not triumph. Not mastery. Recognition.
Messy art is still art. The uneven line still records the hand. The splotched flower still reaches toward flowerness. The failed attempt may still become a poem. The dyed cloth may still dry beautifully in the wind.
And sometimes, after all the judging and fixing and rinsing, all that is left to do is sit nearby, breathe, and let the imperfect thing exist.
Comments